July 10, 2023
Watch the video here at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuKFkH8ye5w
NEW YORK – New York City Mayor Eric Adams and New York City Corporation Counsel Sylvia O. Hinds-Radix today announced that the City of New York is filing a federal lawsuit against four major distributors of flavored disposable e-cigarettes, the most popular vaping devices among middle-school children and high school youth. The four defendants — Magellan Technology Inc. and Demand Vape, both based in Buffalo, NY; Mahant Krupa 56 LLC d/b/a Empire Vape Distributors, based in Queens; and Star Vape, based in Brooklyn — are alleged to have distributed, and continue to distribute, exotically flavored disposable e-cigarettes to retail vape and smoke shops, convenience stores, and directly to consumers in New York City through online sales, in violation of nearly every applicable federal, New York state, and New York City law governing the sale of such products. Today’s lawsuit seeks to block the four defendants from further sales of these illegal items and seeks both monetary damages and fines.
“There is nothing more important than the health of young New Yorkers, but while these four distributors have chosen profits over people, we won’t sit idly by as they continue to poison our children,” said Mayor Adams. “Even though the packaging and flavoring of some of these products might seem harmless, they are 100 percent harmful. These products are packed with nicotine, a toxic and highly addictive chemical that is particularly damaging to adolescent minds and bodies. We will do whatever it takes to keep our children safe, and today’s lawsuit seeks to put an end to the greedy, harmful, and openly illegal behavior of these four nicotine pushers.”
“The city’s lawsuit represents a significant enforcement step against distributors that are fueling an epidemic of e-cigarette use among youth in our city,” said Corporation Counsel Hinds-Radix. “These defendants continue to supply retail outlets throughout the city with nicotine-laced disposable e-cigarettes in exotic fruit, candy, and dessert-like flavors that are clearly designed to appeal to young people in violation of multiple federal, state, and local laws. The aim of this lawsuit is to put a stop to this illegal conduct and protect our youth against these highly addictive and dangerous products.”
“With this action, the city is moving to protect children and young people and hold responsible parties accountable,” said Deputy Mayor for Health and Human Services Anne Williams-Isom. “The city has supported and will continue to support the health and well-being of every person that calls New York City home.”
“The city proactively created laws that protect the health of young people and reduce tobacco companies’ power to market their harmful products to kids,” said New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Deputy Commissioner and Chief Medical Officer Dr. Michelle Morse. “It is infuriating that these companies think they can bypass our laws to hook children on addictive e-cigarettes. The younger a person begins to smoke or vape, the harder it is to quit. This lawsuit shows that New York City will fight to protect the health of its young people.”
“The Sheriff’s Interagency Task Force will continue to work with our partners to utilize all available solution-driven options in combating these serious health and safety threats caused by illegal, unregulated products,” said New York City Sheriff Anthony Miranda. “Holding manufacturers accountable for enabling, promoting, and selling these products that threaten our children and communities is a necessary step to combating the problem. Selling these products are illegal, and we will continue to remove them from our communities.”
“As a mother of two growing children, I know how important it is to protect the health of our youngest New Yorkers,” said New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga. “Despite being illegal, flavored e-cigarettes continue to make their way into our local retailers, which is one of the reasons why DCWP recently stepped-up enforcement against stores that sell tobacco and e-cigarette products to minors or sell these products without a license. Thank you to the Law Department and Mayor Adams for taking action against these distributors and working to protect New Yorkers.”
Most e-liquids provide nicotine levels far exceeding that of conventional cigarettes — some have as much nicotine as 175 to 350 cigarettes. Additionally, federal health authorities, such as the U.S. surgeon general and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), say youth-friendly flavors in e-cigarettes, such as “strawberry milkshake,” “cola,” and “pina colada” are among the flavors that tempt kids to “vape” high levels of nicotine. Child-friendly, cartoon character packaging on e-cigarettes targeted at young people has also contributed to the epidemic of nicotine addiction among middle and high school youth.
Between 2017 and 2019, e-cigarette use among young people nearly doubled. In October 2022, the FDA and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention released federal data from the 2022 National Youth Tobacco Survey finding that one in 10 U.S. middle and high school students had used e-cigarettes in a 30-day sample period. Specifically, 14.1 percent (2.14 million) of high school students and 3.3 percent (380,000) of middle school students reported current e-cigarette use. Flavored e-liquids were used by 81 percent of first-time users, aged 12 to 17, who had ever used electronic nicotine delivery devices, and 85.3 percent of current youth users had used a flavored e-liquid in the past month.
Consistent with the national trend, e-cigarette consumption in New York City schools has climbed in recent years. The 2019 Youth Risk Behavior Survey revealed that 15.2 percent of public high school students and 6.7 percent of public middle school students surveyed reported current use of electronic vapor products.
All this led the FDA, in January 2020, to ban flavored vape products. Flavor bans have also been enacted in New York state and New York City, as well as in many other cities and states nationwide. Additionally, the federal Prevent All Cigarette Trafficking Act prohibits anything other than face-to-face sales of disposable e-cigarettes unless the sales comply with all state and local laws of the jurisdiction in which the sale occurs. This is an impossibility in New York City and in New York state where the New York Public Health Code and the New York City Administrative Code prohibit the sale of flavored disposable e-cigarettes altogether.
Despite these laws, city agencies documented thousands of illegal sales of flavored vapes by city stores in 2022, levying thousands of dollars in fines. In January of this year, deputies from the New York City Sheriff’s Office seized hundreds of thousands of dollars’ worth of illegal flavored vapes from stores located on the Upper West Side. More recently, in May of this year, investigators were able to purchase flavored disposable e-cigarettes from vape and smoke shops, as well as convenience stores throughout the city. Overall, since the formation of the Joint Interagency Task Force convened by Mayor Adams last December, the Sheriff’s Office has seized 319,636 packages of flavored vape, with an estimated value of $6.4 million dollars.
The defendants named in today’s lawsuit include:
The lawsuit — filed today in the U.S District Court for the Southern District of New York —seeks to enjoin all four defendants from further illegal sales that not only constitute a public nuisance and mail and wire fraud, but are also specifically in violation of New York City’s Administrative Code, New York State Public Health Law, the federal Tobacco Control Act, the federal Racketeering Influenced Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act, and the federal government’s Prevent All Cigarette Trafficking Act. The city also seeks to recover monetary damages and civil penalties from the defendants, potentially totaling millions.
“New York banned flavored vape sales in 2019, but that hasn’t prevented teens — the group especially vulnerable to the addictive and harmful effects of Nicotine — from being enticed by and purchasing vapes,” said New York City Councilmember Lynn Schulman, chair, Committee on Health. Thank you to Mayor Eric Adams for protecting the lives of our young New Yorkers by bringing a federal lawsuit against the distributors of theses illegal and dangerous products.”
“I credit the administration for taking enforcement a big step further by going after manufactures of disposable vaping devices in addition to busting individual retailers,” said New York City Councilmember Gale A. Brewer. “It is appropriate to seek money damages from companies that push harmful products that are banned in New York City and come in flavors like bubblegum and cotton candy. We know who is making these vapes and we should hold them responsible for the public health costs.”
“The city's proactive step to crack down on illegal e-cigarette sales is a commendable effort to protect public health, especially the well-being of young people. The increased availability of these products has led to a surge in youth vaping, which is a public health crisis,” said New York City Councilmember Marjorie Velázquez. “By holding distributors accountable for illegal sales, we can protect consumers and prevent them from falling victim to the harmful consequences associated with e-cigarette use.”
“These flavored e-cigarettes are made to appeal to younger people and children, and I am glad that this city is taking action to prevent this health issue from impacting the next generation,” said New York City Councilmember Joann Ariola. “We have already seen a wide array of health issues related to the use of e-cigarettes, and I believe this is a great step forward for a healthier, vapor-free future.”
“Flavored tobacco products remain a major cause of another generation of kids getting hooked on these deadly products,” said Michael Seilback, national assistant vice president, state policy, American Lung Association. “The American Lung Association applauds Mayor Adams and the City of New York for holding these distributors of flavored tobacco products accountable for illegally pushing their products into neighborhoods citywide. The City of New York, the state of New York and the federal government must continue to use all tools at their disposal to stop the importation, distribution and sale of all flavored tobacco products including menthol cigarettes, flavored e-cigarettes and flavored cigars.”
“The lawsuit announced by Mayor Adams is a positive first step to crack down on companies that are putting kids at risk and violating state and city laws that prohibit the sale of all flavored e-cigarettes,” said Yolonda C. Richardson, president and CEO, Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids. “Flavored e-cigarettes, including both disposable and refillable products, have fueled the continuing youth nicotine addiction crisis. To end this crisis, New York City must fully enforce its law and stop the sale of all flavored e-cigarettes.”
“Founded in 2018 by three New York City moms around a kitchen table, Parents Against Vaping E-cigarettes — the first national parent voice fighting youth tobacco use and the predatory behavior of the tobacco industry — is enormously grateful to Mayor Eric Adams and the Corporation Counsel for today’s landmark legal actions that we believe should be a model for other cities across the country,” said Meredith Berkman and Dorian Fuhrman, co-founders, Parents Against Vaping E-cigarettes. “We hear from New York City parents every single day that yet another unlicensed tobacco retailer has opened in their neighborhood and is selling illegal flavored vapes to local kids. Cracking down on these bad actors is important and urgently needed, but going after the distributors themselves — the source of these dangerous and highly-addictive youth-marketed flavored products — is the most effective way to protect our kids from becoming a generation of nicotine addicts and the tobacco industry’s next generation of lifetime customers."
“Similar to traditional cigarettes, E-cigarettes are easily accessible to youth at local convenience stores and are highly visible in the media,” said Lisa David, president and CEO, Public Health Solutions. “The tobacco industry is using strategies that were banned for cigarettes in the 1990’s for youth-targeted marketing today. Many people are unaware that e-cigarettes are considered tobacco products because they contain nicotine, which comes from tobacco. Nicotine is a dangerous and addictive substance that can harm adolescent brain development. We don’t need more access points for our youth to become hooked on tobacco products. We at Public Health Solutions (PHS) thank Mayor Adams for taking this bold action, and we will continue the fight to ensure all NYC residents are aware of the dangers of tobacco use and the deceptive tactics of the tobacco industry.”