
Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings311
Search all NYC.gov websites
Sign up to receive OATH BenchNOTES in your email inbox.
CityAdmin Notice: The OATH decision database has moved. The CityAdmin Document Repository is now hosted by the City of New York and can be found here: https://nyc.mindbreeze.com/search/apps/cityadmin/.
Contract Dispute Resolution Board Panelists: OATH is accepting applications from qualified persons to serve on Contract Dispute Resolution Board (CDRB) panels. CDRB panels hear the final appeal in a three-step dispute resolution process contained in City contracts for construction, goods and services. Each CDRB panel consists of an OATH Administrative Law Judge, as chair, a representative of the Mayor’s Office of Contract Services, and a third member, selected from a pre-qualified roster of individuals, established and administered by OATH, who has appropriate expertise and is unaffiliated with and not employed by the City.
Those interested in being added to the roster of pre-qualified individuals are encouraged to apply. Applicants should have a background and experience in government contracting, construction, engineering or related law. The application form, as well as more information on the panelist role, can be found here. Completed applications should be sent via e-mail to the OATH Trials Division Law Clerks, LawClerks@oath.nyc.gov.
ALJ Christine Stecura recommended a 60-day suspension after finding that a Parks Department supervisor sexually harassed a coworker while on duty. Dep’t of Parks & Recreation v. Dunnell, OATH Index No. 1140/26 (June 12, 2026), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (June 29, 2026).
Read more about Dep’t of Parks & Recreation v. Dunnell.
ALJ Seon Jeong Lee recommended continuing the license suspension of a TLC-licensed driver charged with assault in the third degree while on duty after he exited his vehicle and punched the complainant, a pedestrian, causing the complainant to fall to the ground. Taxi & Limousine Comm’n v. Alonzo, OATH Index No. 2084/26 (June 9, 2026), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (July 9, 2026).
Read more about Taxi & Limousine Comm’n v. Alonzo and other licensing cases.
ALJ Michael D. Turilli determined that the Police Department may retain a vehicle seized as an alleged instrumentality of a crime, where the driver was arrested on an outstanding warrant, pursuant to which a firearm was lawfully recovered from respondent’s person. Police Dep’t v. Cromwell, OATH Index No. 2251/26, mem. dec. (June 25, 2026).
Read more about Police Dep’t v. Cromwell.
The Contract Dispute Resolution Board, chaired by ALJ Hanchun Lin, denied in part and granted in part claims brought on behalf of a subcontractor against the Department of Design and Construction regarding contracts for the rehabilitation, elevation, and reconstruction of homes damaged by Hurricane Sandy. LiRo Program & Construction Management, PE P.C. (o/b/o Navesink Prestige LLC) v. Dep’t of Design & Construction, OATH Index Nos. 1426/24 & 1427/24, mem. dec. (June 24, 2026).
An appellate decision affirmed a hearing decision sustaining a violation of § 16-120(a) of the New York City Administrative Code for improper receptacles. Petitioner’s case rested on the affirmed statements in the summonses that refuse was not placed out for collection in rigid containers with tight fitting lids. On appeal, as at the hearing, respondent asserted that it was physically and legally impossible to comply with the law because the only area where trash receptacles could be stored was the building lobby, which would illegally obstruct the means of egress. The appellate decision found that respondent had not established an impossibility defense because per § 1-02.1(d) of Title 16 of the Rules of the City of New York, “[i]f other storage areas on the premises are not available, receptacles may be stored in the area within 3 feet of the building line on the sidewalk, provided that such receptacles are maintained in an orderly manner and do not impede or obstruct pedestrian flow on the sidewalk.” DSNY v. Manhattan Realty Company 1 LP, Appeal No. 2600534 (June 25, 2026).
An appellate decision reversed part of a hearing decision imposing an Aggravated I penalty for a Class 2 violation of § 28-204.4 of the New York City Administrative Code. Petitioner’s case rested on the affirmed statements in the summons that respondent failed to comply with a Commissioner’s order contained in a summons issued for a vehicle parked in the front yard. At the hearing, petitioner submitted two prior summonses, each charging respondent with a violation of § 28-301.1 of the Administrative Code for an illegal curb cut at the front of the property giving access to an illegal off-street parking space. On appeal, respondent maintained that the Aggravated I penalty was not supported by the prior summonses because the charged violations were based on an illegal parking space, while the instant summons charged respondent with failing to file a certificate of correction. The appellate decision agreed with respondent’s argument, finding that the violating condition in the prior summonses was different from the violating condition in the instant summons. The appellate decision concluded that an Aggravated I penalty could not be imposed, because as per § 102-01(f)(1) of Title 1 of the Rules of the City of New York, such penalty may only be imposed “when evidence establishes the same condition or the same charge under the New York City Construction Codes . . . in a prior enforcement action against the same owner or responsible party during the previous three years.” DOB v. Mayer Ziegler, Appeal No. 2600540 (June 25, 2026).
An appellate decision reversed a hearing decision dismissing a third-offense charge of § 24-163 of the New York City Administrative Code for idling a motor vehicle for more than three minutes. Petitioner’s case rested on affirmed statements in the summons alleging that a citizen-complainant observed respondent’s van idling for more than three minutes. The judicial hearing officer dismissed the violation based on respondent’s claim that the van was idling to operate a Perfluorocarbon Tracer (“PFT”), a processing device used to detect subsurface gas leaks. The appellate decision found that respondent’s own evidence claiming that the van engine must be turned on in order to charge a lithium-ion battery bank, to which an inverter was connected to power the PFT, showed that the PFT was not mechanically connected to the van’s engine and therefore did not meet the definition of “processing device” found in § 39-01 of Title 15 of the Rules of the City of New York. Therefore, it concluded that respondent failed to establish a defense to the charge. DEP v. Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc., Appeal No. 2600541 (June 25, 2026).