“I’m deeply honored by this
invitation to address the World Bank Group’s Urban Sector. Your work you do in
so many rapidly growing cities puts you center stage in the world’s most
important drama.
“And you should be proud of the
difference you’re making to so many that need society’s help. You are truly at
the center of our rapidly changing world. This year, for the first time in human
history, city dwellers will begin to make up the majority of the Earth’s
population. This global urbanization represents a seismic shift in world affairs
– and it’s happening at a breathtaking pace. Fifty years ago, fewer than 100 of
the world’s cities had populations of one million or more people. Within ten
years, nearly 500 will.
“For example, 50 years ago,
China was still a largely agrarian
nation. But by the middle of our current century, it’s expected that as much as
three-fourths of the Chinese population will live in cities. I was there two
months ago, and two things are true:
They’ve made enormous progress – and they have staggering problems
ahead.
“Such astonishing growth has thrust
major new responsibilities onto the shoulders of those of us working in the
world’s large cities. All of us, in every country, today face – daily and
directly – the economic, social, and environmental consequences of explosive
urban growth. In addition, we now have to deal with the forces of globalization
and climate change. And we also must confront the challenge of providing all our
people with the health and social services they need to create better lives for
their families.
“As citizens of the world, our duties are great – but so
are the opportunities for building a more secure and prosperous world for
everyone: a world where anything that can be imagined, can be achieved – whether
that’s ending illiteracy or hunger, or stopping the AIDS epidemic, or cleaning the air, or deterring corruption. The World Bank
has a critically important role to play in these and other areas. So does the UN.
So do the developed countries. And so do all of us
who are lucky enough to have shared what I describe as the Great
American Dream – a dream that also embodies the aspirations of people around
the globe.
“Some people doubt that the world’s
cities are up to the tasks before us. I don’t. Time after time, cities have
shown an ability to overcome even the most daunting obstacles, and to mobilize
and maximize the talents of our people. Today, I’d like to use the
transformation of New
York as a small example of what can be done – although
God knows you help those with infinitely more serious problems in just staying
alive.
“In the days immediately
following 9/11, many thoughtful people believed that New York’s days of
greatness were numbered. There were serious predictions that businesses and
residents would flee the city wholesale, that our economy would never recover,
that crime would once again take root in our city, and that New York was headed into
an irreversible downward spiral of decline.
“Sound familiar? I would bet that
all of you here have heard the naysayers and cynics tell you why your efforts at
the World Bank won’t succeed – why you can’t succeed. We’ve heard the same in my
city. But over the past six years,
New York City
has proved the naysayers wrong – and you will too!
“How? There’s no one answer, of course, no
royal road to success. But I believe that four values which have helped
transform New
York provide lessons that are universal and
transferable. They are: harnessing
the forces of immigration and globalization; tapping the power of innovation;
instituting rigorous and accountable governance; and having the independence to
take on entrenched interests when they stand in the way of progress.
“Let me expand on each of those
values, beginning with the long-term and continuing embrace of immigration and
globalization. If you want to know the biggest difference between New York and the cities
that never recovered from the job losses of the 1970s, I have one word for you:
immigrants.
“Over the past 30 years, our
immigrant population has more than doubled in size. Today 37% of New Yorkers – more than
three million people – are foreign-born, and more than 70% of them have come to
New York since
1980. Their ambition, hard work, and entrepreneurial drive continue to bring
dynamic new life to our economy and a fresh new spirit to our city. New Yorkers
understand that. Even after 9/11,
when it would have been understandable for us to become fearful about the rest
of the world, we have continued to welcome immigrants at a history-making pace.
And they have more than repaid us.
“Just as important as this global
movement of people is the increasingly crucial role that global capital plays in
New York’s
economy. We finance development
around the world – and you see today other countries investing in New York. International –
and multi-directional.
“The power of globalization played a big part in
reviving New York’s fortunes over the past 30 years, and preventing us from
going into a downward spiral after 9/11. And our success story is far from being
a ‘one-off’ anomaly in today’s world. Just look at what India and China have
achieved as they have become more urbanized and more fully re-integrated into
the global economy. What this tells us is that the world’s cities emphatically
do not need the restrictive new barriers to immigration or trade that many
political leaders want to erect, especially here in the U.S.
“The cities that hope to
succeed in the 21st century cannot close their doors to the world’s workers
anymore than they can close their doors to the world’s capital or the world’s
ideas. In New
York, the free, global movement of labor, capital, and
ideas defines our character, underlies our prosperity, and explains our
comeback.
“Sadly, some of our national leaders
are turning their backs on this formula for success. And if they insist on turning away the
best and the brightest, and protecting jobs instead of promoting them, then the
hard economic times that we are beginning to experience here in the U.S.
will be with us for a long time.
“The choice is ours – and every
country faces the same choice: Do we reap the benefits of globalization and
address its difficulties honestly or do we scapegoat globalization and turn away
its benefits? I believe we should be working to bring the benefits of
globalization not only to the U.S., but to cities around the world
where too many people remain isolated and impoverished – something that the
World Bank’s lending policies can help achieve.
“One of the benefits of
globalization is the ever freer movement of ideas – a trend that reinforces the
second value I want to stress: the
power of innovation. There are so many educated, creative, brilliant minds in
our world today, capable of creating innovative solutions to many, if not all of
the problems that plague us. We must foster this spirit of innovation and
reinforce it at every turn.
“New York – and other cities, too – understand
this. We are increasingly adopting
one another’s innovative approaches to our shared challenges. This is especially
true in two areas: reducing poverty and global climate change.
“In the
U.S., we’ve been fighting poverty
with pretty much the same arsenal of weapons for the past 40 years. And guess what? Not much has changed. That’s why
innovation that promises to break this cycle of futility is so crucial. So far, there’s been precious
little talk of innovation at the national level – in our government, or in our
current political campaigns.
“But the world’s cities
– including New
York – aren’t waiting for others to act first. Countries
around the world, especially in the developing world, are experimenting with
anti-poverty programs that smash taboos and turn orthodoxies on their head – and
some of them have had very promising results.
“That’s why New York has recently become the first U.S.
city to adopt – on a trial basis – the kind of ‘conditional cash transfers’ that
have been a success in Mexico, Turkey, Brazil, and other developing nations. And
I’m pleased to see that Prime Minister Brown of Great Britain is now proposing a
similar program for the United Kingdom. By offering conditional cash payments that can
amount to up to one-third of household income, we hope to encourage low-income New Yorkers to stay in
school, stay in their jobs, and stay on track to rise out of poverty.
“Nearly 5,000 families are now
enrolled in ‘Opportunity NYC.’ This
program is currently funded privately; if it becomes the success we hope it will
be, we’ll invest public dollars in it. The World Bank has long been a leader in
supporting conditional cash transfers, and I want to thank its staff for working
with us as we designed and set up Opportunity NYC. That includes, in particular,
Laura Rawlings of the Bank’s Caribbean and
Latin American regional office.
“New York and other cities
are also sharing innovative ideas about addressing an equally critical
issue: climate change. Indeed, in many instances, cities are
well out in front of their national governments in this area, too. For example,
even though our national government has not ratified the Kyoto Accord, more than
700 American cities, including New
York, have pledged to meet its standards.
“In the past year, I’ve
met and talked with mayors of the world’s great cities, from London, to Mexico City, to
Beijing. We
recognize that, as New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman has written, when it
comes to climate change, ‘It’s too late for later.’ So we’re not waiting for
others to act first. Increasingly,
we’re working in concert with one another, and adopting one another’s best
practices in areas ranging from ‘greening’ our streets to cleaning our air.
“New
York’s sustainability agenda – called PlaNYC – draws on the policies of cities
around the world, from Berlin to
Singapore. New York City will extend
and encourage that exchange of ideas when we host a major two-day international
conference on climate change and urban air quality in June.
“The World Bank Group has shown its
own leadership on climate change, starting with the example you’ve set by
becoming a ‘carbon neutral’ organization. Now your lending practices can support
the world’s cities as we find innovative ways to shrink our carbon footprints,
too.
“But to be effective, innovation has
to be coupled with the third value that I want to stress: Rigorous and publicly
accountable governance – governance that is transparent, efficient, and that
makes decisions based on data. There’s a saying: ‘In God we trust. Everyone else bring data.’ I’ve found
that in business and government, those are good words to live by.
“In New York City, we’ve not only used data to
drive decisions, we’ve made it transparent – so that the public will be able to
see where the problems lie. That’s why, for example, we’ve begun grading all
1,500 of our public schools – the schools, not just the kids – so that parents
will know how their child’s school compares to other schools. If their children
go to a school that’s failing, will they yell and scream until things get
better? They should! And that’s exactly the point.
“Accurate, transparent, and
continually collected data is also crucial to deciding when and how to most
efficiently use scarce resources. Public safety is a prime example. During 2007, New
York City had fewer homicides than we have had in any year since 1963
– cementing our hold on the title of ‘America’s safest big city.’
“We’ve done that by relentlessly
mapping crime trends and deploying officers accordingly. And we’ve done that
even as our police force has shrunk by some 5,000 officers over the past six
years, and even as the police department has assumed extensive new intelligence
and anti-terrorism responsibilities in the wake of 9/11.
“In American cities, just as in the
global development community, some people will tell you that the solution to any
problem is easy: More money. But in New York, we’ve learned that while more money
is always nice, it also really is possible to do more with less.
“We can attack problems most
effectively by rigorous analysis and a high-accountability approach: identifying
the communities in greatest need.., driving resources to them, and holding
front-line workers responsible for success. Such rigorous, accountable
governance also allows us to direct funds that might otherwise be wasted to
investments in the infrastructure that our growing city needs.
“To cite just one example: We are now on course to complete a third
water tunnel that is vital to New
York’s future. It’s a project that had stopped and
stalled for more than 30 years – in large part because every time the economy
slowed, the easy out politically was to cut infrastructure spending while
maintaining spending on popular programs. This kind of approach will not solve
the problems that we must solve. Through accountable governance, we’ve shown
that it’s possible to sustain, and even improve, basic services, while also
investing in the City’s future.
“Finally, let me turn to
the fourth value I want to stress:
political independence. In reforming our schools, in reinventing our
social services, in area after area, we’ve been willing to touch the so-called
‘third rail’ issues that others have avoided. The reason, quite simply, is that
the political independence of our Administration has allowed us to take on
vested interests, and let the chips fall where they may.
“I’ve found that when you do this,
the voters – even if they don’t agree with you on everything – will respect you,
because they know that you’re making decisions based on the merits, not based on
polls or partisanship or political calculus.
“A good example of how
we’ve been independent – and one with global implications – concerns the largest
single cause of preventable death worldwide: Tobacco. Over the past six years,
New York City
has been very pro-active against smoking – often in the face of stiff and vocal
opposition.
“We’ve raised cigarette taxes, mounted aggressive public
information campaigns, increased smoking cessation programs, and outlawed
smoking in all public places, including restaurants and bars. And if you want a
character-building experience, I suggest doing that, and then marching in a St. Patrick’s Day parade that goes past
the city’s pubs.
You’d be surprised how many one-fingered waves you
get!
“But let me tell you, this is an
area where political independence – a willingness to fight the vested interests
– has really paid off. We’ve cut smoking among adult New Yorkers by 20% during
the past six years and reduced teen smoking by 52%. That translates into a quarter-million
fewer smokers, untold millions, short- and long-term, in saved dollars in health
care costs, and even more importantly, saved lives.
“Now we need to write the same kind
of success story worldwide. And to
do that, your help is needed in supporting the city and national leaders who are
willing to show political independence in the face of the powerful vested
interests promoting tobacco use. As you may know, developing countries already
account for 70% of cigarette consumption. And tobacco companies are stepping
up their marketing in the developing world.
“As The Economist put it recently,
‘The tobacco industry is getting the world’s poor hooked before governments can
respond.’ Unless we do respond, the result will be a public health calamity: One
billion pre-mature deaths – from cancer, stroke, and heart disease – in this
century, many of them in the cities where you work.
“In response, my foundation
supported a recent World Health Organization study of tobacco habits and
policies in 179 different countries. If we want countries to change their
policies, we first had to know scope of the problem. That’s just the first step
in what is going to be a long struggle, fought on many fronts. But as New York City has shown: This is a winnable fight – one that the
world’s other cities and nations now must also join. Again, I ask you to join me in
this effort.
“Globalization,
innovation, accountable governance, independent leadership: Each of you in your work in cities
around the world has the opportunity to foster these values. The 21st century
will see an increasingly urban world – on every continent on our globe. Now it’s up to all of us to ensure that
the residents of the world’s cities enjoy a safer, healthier, and more secure
future.
“Every generation, in its own way,
faces the challenge of enlarging the realm of human happiness and opening up new
vistas of human possibility.
“When we talk about ‘building better
cities’ in our world, that’s truly what’s at stake. We have the knowledge, we
have the resources, and I believe we all have the will!
“I want to thank each of you in the
World Bank Group for working to meet that challenge. Good luck to you all – may your efforts
here, and in cities everywhere, be crowned with success.”