| Mayor | Term |
| 1. Thomas Willett | 1665* |
| 2. Thomas Delavall | 1666 |
| 3. Thomas Willett | 1667 |
| 4. Cornelius Steenwyck | 1668-1670 |
| 5. Thomas Delavall | 1671 |
| 6. Matthias Nicolls | 1672 |
| 7. John Lawrence | 1673 |
| 8. William Dervall | 1675 |
| 9. Nicholas De Meyer | 1676 |
| 10. Stephanus Van Cortlandt | 1677 |
| 11. Thomas Delavall | 1678 |
| 12. Francis Rombouts | 1679 |
| 13. William Dyre | 1680-1681 |
| 14. Cornelius Steenwyck | 1682-1683 |
| 15. Gabriel Minvielle | 1684 |
| 16. Nicholas Bayard | 1685 |
| 17. S. Van Cortlandt | 1686-1688 |
| 18. Peter Delanoy | 1689-1690 |
| 19. John Lawrence | 1691 |
| 20. Abraham De Peyster | 1692-1694 |
| 21. Charles Lodwik | 1694-1695 |
| 22. William Merrett | 1695-1698 |
| 23. Johannes De Peyster | 1698-1699 |
| 24. David Provost | 1699-1700 |
| 25. Isaac de Reimer | 1700-1701 |
| 26. Thomas Noell | 1701-1702 |
| 27. Philip French | 1702-1703 |
| 28. William Peartree | 1703-1707 |
| 29. Ebenezer Wilson | 1707-1710 |
| 30. Jacobus Van Cortlandt | 1710-1711 |
| 31. Caleb Heathcote | 1711-1714 |
| 32. John Johnson | 1714-1719 |
| 33. Jacobus Van Cortlandt | 1719-1720 |
| 34. Robert Walters | 1720-1725 |
| 35. Johannes Jansen | 1725-1726 |
| 36. Robert Lurting | 1726-1735 |
| 37. Paul Richard | 1735-1739 |
| 38. John Cruger | 1739-1744 |
| 39. Stephen Bayard | 1744-1747 |
| 40. Edward Holland | 1747-1757 |
| 41. John Cruger, Jr. | 1757-1766 |
| 42. Whitehead Hicks | 1766-1776 |
| 43. David Mathews | 1776-1784 |
| 44. James Duane | 1784-1789 |
| 45. Richard Varick | 1789-1801 |
| 46. Edward Livingston | 1801-1803 |
| 47. De Witt Clinton | 1803-1807 |
| 48. Marinus Willett | 1807-1808 |
| 49. De Witt Clinton | 1808-1810 |
| 50. Jacob Radcliff | 1810-1811 |
| 51. De Witt Clinton | 1811-1815 |
| 52. John Ferguson | 1815 |
| 53. Jacob Radcliff | 1815-1818 |
| 54. Cadwallader D. Colden | 1818-1821 |
| 55. Stephen Allen | 1821-1824 |
| 56. William Paulding | 1825-1826 |
| 57. Philip Hone | 1826-1827 |
| 58. William Paulding | 1827-1829 |
| 59. Walter Bowne | 1829-1833 |
| 60. Gideon Lee | 1833-1834 |
| 61. Cornelius W. Lawrence | 1834-1837 |
| 62. Aaron Clark | 1837-1839 |
| 63. Isaac L. Varian | 1839-1841 |
| 64. Robert H. Morris | 1841-1844 |
| 65. James Harper | 1844-1845 |
| 66. William F. Havemeyer | 1845-1846 |
| 67. Andrew H. Mickle | 1846-1847 |
| 68. William V. Brady | 1847-1848 |
| 69. William F. Havemeyer | 1848-1849 |
| 70. Caleb S. Woodhull | 1849-1851 |
| 71. Ambrose C. Kingsland | 1851-1853 |
| 72. Jacob A. Westervelt | 1853-1855 |
| 73. Fernando Wood | 1855-1858 |
| 74. Daniel F. Tiemann | 1858-1860 |
| 75. Fernando Wood | 1860-1862 |
| 76. George Opdyke | 1862-1864 |
| 77. C. Godfrey Gunther | 1864-1866 |
| 78. John T. Hoffman | 1866-1868 |
| | **T. Coman | 1868 |
| 79. A. Oakey Hall | 1869-1872 |
| 80. William F. Havemeyer | 1873-1874 |
| | **S.B.H. Vance | 1874 |
| 81. William H. Wickham | 1875-1876 |
| 82. Smith Ely | 1877-1878 |
| 83. Edward Cooper | 1879-1880 |
| 84. William R. Grace | 1881-1882 |
| 85. Franklin Edson | 1883-1884 |
| 86. William R. Grace | 1885-1886 |
| 87. Abram S. Hewitt | 1887-1888 |
| 88. Hugh J. Grant | 1889-1892 |
| 89. Thomas F. Gilroy | 1893-1894 |
| 90. William L. Strong | 1895-1897 |
| 91. Robert A. Van Wyck | 1898-1901 |
| 92. Seth Low | 1902-1903 |
| 93. George B. McClellan | 1904-1909 |
| 94. William J. Gaynor | 1910-1913 |
| | **Ardolph L. Kline | 1913 |
| 95. John Purroy Mitchel | 1914-1917 |
| 96. John F. Hylan | 1918-1925 |
| 97. †James J. Walker | 1926-1932 |
| | **Joseph V. McKee | 1932 |
| 98. John P. O'Brien | 1933 |
| 99. Fiorello H. LaGuardia | 1934-1945 |
| 100. ††William O'Dwyer | 1946-1950 |
| 101. ***Vincent R. Impellitteri | 1950-1953 |
| 102. Robert F. Wagner | 1954-1965 |
| 103. John V. Lindsay | 1966-1973 |
| 104. Abraham D. Beame | 1974-1977 |
| 105. Edward I. Koch | 1978-1989 |
| 106. David N. Dinkins | 1990-1993 |
| 107. Rudolph W. Giuliani | 1994- 2001 |
| 108. Michael R. Bloomberg | 2002- |
*Prior to June 15, 1665 (when New Amsterdam was captured by the British), the City was headed by Burgomasters.
**Acting Mayor.
†Resigned Sept. 1, 1932.
††Resigned Sept. 2, 1950.
***Acting Mayor from Sept. 2, 1950 to Nov. 14, 1950. Elected Mayor Nov. 7, 1950.